Coin grading is the process of evaluating a coin’s condition and quality based on various factors like its appearance, wear, and overall preservation.
Grading helps establish the coin's value, as higher-quality coins are typically worth more. Grading systems provide a standardized way of describing the coin's condition, so that collectors, investors, and dealers can communicate clearly about a coin's quality.
The most commonly used grading scale for modern coins is the Sheldon Scale, which runs from 1 to 70. A coin’s grade is often expressed as a number (e.g., MS-65 or AU-50) to indicate its quality, with MS standing for "Mint State" and AU standing for "About Uncirculated."
Here’s a breakdown of the coin grading system, from worst to best:
1. Poor (P-1)
- This is the lowest grade. The coin is so worn and damaged that only a few details may be visible, if any.
-Extremely worn, possibly corroded, or barely identifiable.
-A coin with nearly no visible features, just the outlines or basic shape.
2. Fair (FR-2)
-A severely worn coin where major details have been worn away, but some identifying features or inscriptions may still be visible.
-Major portions of the design are missing, but the coin is still identifiable.
-The date or mint mark may be worn down, but some of the main features are still visible.
3. About Good (AG-3)
- More wear than Fair coins, but at least some major features are still recognizable.
- A significant amount of the design is worn away, but it remains identifiable, especially for collectors of low-grade or affordable coins. Some parts of the coin’s design are difficult to discern, but the coin is still recognizable.
4. Good (G-4)
-Considered well-worn, but key design elements are still visible, although often faint.
-The coin has extensive wear, but the basic features are still legible, especially the most important parts like the date and mintmark.
-You can make out the major design features, but much of the fine detail has been lost.
5. Very Good (VG-8)
-Some signs of wear, but more design elements are visible compared to the Good grade.
-The coin is worn, but many of the finer details of the design can still be seen.
-Some finer details might be worn away, but the design is still distinct, and the date is visible.
6. Fine (F-12)
-A coin with moderate wear, but the design is still clearly defined.
-The coin shows wear, but much of the design, including finer details, remains visible.
-The coin may show some flattening or wear, but the features like hair details, eyes, and mintmarks are clearly discernible.
7. Very Fine (VF-20)
- The coin has moderate wear but the design elements are still sharp and distinct.
- Light to moderate wear, with only slight flattening of the design's finer details.
- The coin's fine details (like hair strands, drapery, and facial features) are worn, but still quite visible.
8. Extremely Fine (XF-40 or EF-40)
- A coin with very minimal wear. The design remains almost fully intact, showing only slight wear.
- Very light wear in the high points of the coin (such as the tops of letters or figures).
- The design is well-defined with just slight signs of wear, like on the high points (e.g., the tops of letters or figures).
9. About Uncirculated (AU-50, AU-53, AU-55)
- The coin shows very little wear, and most of the design remains intact. It is often difficult to distinguish it from an uncirculated coin.
- Slight wear on the highest points of the design, but otherwise, the coin still looks like it could have been freshly minted.
- Just the slightest wear, such as some rub on the high points, like the head of a figure or the edges of the coin’s design.
Mint State (MS-60 to MS-70)
These grades are for coins that have never been used in circulation and remain in pristine condition.
10. Mint State (MS-60)
- A coin that is uncirculated but has noticeable imperfections (like bag marks or scratches).
- The coin may have some imperfections from handling or storage, but it has no wear from circulation.
- A coin that’s been handled but still has all its original details intact.
11. Mint State (MS-63 to MS-64)
- The coin has minor imperfections but no obvious signs of wear.
- Slight bag marks or small scratches may be visible, but the coin still has high eye appeal and no wear from circulation.
- Coin may have small abrasions from handling, but it's still visually appealing overall.
12. Mint State (MS-65)
- A coin in near-perfect condition, with only very minor imperfections.
- Small imperfections may be present, but the coin appears almost flawless to the naked eye.
- Very few imperfections visible, and they are usually only noticeable under magnification.
13. Mint State (MS-66 to MS-69)
- These coins are extremely well-preserved, with only the faintest imperfections visible under magnification.
- Exceptional quality and eye appeal, with only very minor blemishes or handling marks.
- The coin is nearly perfect, but you might see the smallest marks under a microscope or magnifying glass.
14. Mint State (MS-70)
- Perfect condition, with no imperfections of any kind.
- The coin is flawless with perfect luster, sharp details, and absolutely no visible marks. MS-70 is the highest grade a coin can achieve.
- A coin in perfect condition with no imperfections, visible only under a magnifying glass.
Other Important Terms
- Specially made coins, often for collectors, that are minted using polished dies and usually have a mirror-like finish. These coins are graded separately, often with grades like PR-70 (Proof-70), which indicates perfection in proof condition.
- Coins that have been cleaned, damaged, or altered may be graded as "Details" rather than a numerical grade (e.g., "AU Details" or "Cleaned"). These coins may still be valuable, but their altered condition lowers their appeal to collectors.
Summary:
- (grades from P-1 to AU-50) are coins that have been used in circulation and show varying signs of wear.
- (grades from AU-50 to MS-60) are coins that have entered circulation and are in varying states of preservation.
- (grades from MS-60 to MS-70) are coins that have not been used in circulation but are in such a condition that it is barely noticeable with an increasing premium price range from this level of grading upwards
- (graded PR-60 to PR-70) are specially struck and usually of higher quality than regular circulation coins.
Coin grading helps to set market values and gives collectors a way to evaluate a coin's investment potential based on its condition. Higher-grade coins, especially those that are uncirculated or perfect, typically command higher prices.
Get in touch if you have more questions or want to dive deeper into any part of coin grading!
